From Times Of Israel, 8-1-2020
For the full (quite long) article go
to https://tinyurl.com/t3px5uz
The word “colonialism”
brings to mind many things. Most notably, it is a term associated with European
imperialist adventures in the “New World” and all of the attendant horrors that
followed. It invokes, in specie, mental images of white-European settlers,
armed with Bibles and bayonets, dominating “less advanced” indigenous populations
And since nearly all of
these and other more infamous examples of colonialism were specifically
white-European, the concept itself has come to be seen as associated with white supremacism.
It is under this rubric, and in conjunction with the postmodern progressive
fixation on racial justice that Zionism has been cast as a “colonial” movement,
while the ongoing Arab effort to reverse the gains made by the indigenous
Jewish people in 1948 is championed as “anti-colonialism”.
Zionism, however, is not
colonialism, but the polar opposite thereof. To understand why this is so, it
is important to clearly define both of these concepts.
Colonialism is, at a
baseline level, the practice of expropriating foreign territory and
incorporating it into a metropole, or “mother country” (e.g. the British
Crown). This process typically entails occupying these new lands with settlers,
suppressing local indigenous populations, and enforcing the tongue, culture,
and lifestyle of the metropole on the aforementioned indigenous inhabitants.
Zionism is an indigenous
people’s repatriation/liberation movement. The yearning to return to our
homeland has been ingrained in our culture ever since we were jettisoned from
our soil by foreign occupiers, primarily into Europe, North Africa, and other
parts of the Middle East.
Zionism is, at its core,
an indigenous rights project, and has been since day one. The Jews returning
from exile had no mother country to “colonize” on behalf of. Israel IS the
mother country.
It is commonly alleged
by anti-Zionists that the early Israelites were themselves conquerors (of
Mesopotamian stock), but this is not corroborated by scholarship.
Now let’s discuss the
real colonialism occurring within Palestine – specifically, that conducted by
Arab Palestine itself.
The Arabs sought to
expand their holdings and their power through acquisition of foreign territory.
Conquest, war, and totalization were the popular mode of “progress” in that
era, so it isn’t surprising that the Arabs sought to build an empire of their own.
Their first conquests included, by dint of proximity, the upper parts of Middle
East, specifically Iraq, Israel, Lebanon, and Syria. They immediately set about
the project of “Arabization”: raising taxes on indigenous peoples, restricting
our government access, curtailing our civil liberties, replacing our sacred
sites with mosques (the most notable example being the Al-Aqsa compound, which
sits on the very location where our Temple once was),
What, then, is the
Palestinian cause? It is, in essence, a reaction to Zionism and the State of
Israel itself. Although it ludicrously presents itself as an indigenous
rights-oriented cause, it is really nothing more than a front for Arab
imperialism. It is hoped that, by repatriating the 6 million or so descendants
of Arab refugees into Israel, the Jews in Israel will be demographically
overwhelmed and we will be robbed of our self-determination once more,
transforming our country into a de facto Arab state.
The Palestinian cause
has nothing whatsoever to do with human rights or “anti-colonialism”. It is
about nothing more than the Arab world’s desire to regain its lost “honor” by
accomplishing through stealth what it failed to do by force: restoring their
hegemony over Israel and putting the “uppity” Jews back in their place.
It is a claim that has been weaponized
against indigenous peoples and used to sweep us under the rug, all in the hope
of removing us from our homelands and ensuring that they remain “Arab”. They’ve
appropriated the Jews histories and identities as their own without actually
belonging to our cultures or suffering for them, and despite centuries of
benefiting from the very same system of colonial domination that led to our
dispossession in the first place.
I
think we have every right to be pissed off about that.
Missing: The bigger part of the today's Arab population of Israel are of foreign origin, from Syria, Egypt, Saudi Arabia etc. They are not indigenous to this area.
ReplyDelete